“Andover’s Historic Church celebrates its 150th Anniversary”

Andover Community Church, formerly called Andover Congregational Church

By Pastor John Wagner

We recently changed our name (formerly Andover Congregational) to Andover Community Church.  A community church may mean different things depending on the church, but “congregational churches” originally, were quite literally churches of the town and community. 

The original settlers of New England brought with them a fervent Christian commitment and the basic form of church parishes with them from old England.  You may have heard these were the “Puritans.” And so they might be called, though originally “puritan” wasn’t a name they had chosen for themselves, but actually a term of derision used by their opponents.  It referred to the desire of these reformers to “purify” the faith and practices of the Church of England, and to “purify” the morals and religious faith of its members (No surprise, they were often resented as meddlers.).  But originally, the Puritans were simply a reforming movement comprised of clergy and laity within the Church of England. Eventually, many thought a better way would be to come to the New World that was opening up to English settlement, and establish model Christian communities and a new life together.  Commercial incentives, no doubt, also played a role, but religious faith was a major concern for many in the 1600s.

Now, on to “community churches:” the early settlers of Massachusetts (and older areas of New Hampshire and other New England states) legally required that worship services with preaching be provided for, before a town could be incorporated. In other words, the citizenry were not only to participate in the government of their new towns (by town meetings, etc.) with elected officials leading them in their civic life; the citizenry of every new town were to participate in the town or “parish” church with their elected clergy leading them in their religious life together. 

Early on compulsory attendance at worship was dropped, but every town still had to provide for preaching and worship for those who wanted it.  The Puritans, or shall we call them “early Congregationalists,” did not reject the idea of “parish churches” (the model they brought with them from old England). What they rejected were those community churches being governed by bishops.  Back in England those being made bishops usually were not men of great piety or even faith, so much as political appointees because of their connections (second sons of nobility, etc.). Congregationalism meant every Christian believer should have a say in running the church, because every true Christian has the Holy Spirit. This of course, led to its own problems. 

Their intention was never to suggest that the Christian religion is a matter of majority vote, or the lowest common denominator of religious ideas  These early people of New England generally believed in “keeping the faith once and for all delivered to the people of God.” This meant that reforming the Church and Christian faith, life, and practice would always lead Christians back to the writings of the Apostles and their “disciples” (the New Testament), and also to the Hebrew Scriptures of Israel (which we know as the Old Testament).

So “community church” may mean different things to different people.  Here in Andover our church building dates back to 1796. We celebrated its 200th anniversary in 1996.  It was originally the parish church “meeting house” of the Town (the second one). The town had arranged for services and preaching since its incorporation, but it was in 1782 that Rev. Josiah Badcock became the first settled pastor, the first and only minister actually called by the town.  After Rev. Badcock retired in 1809, services and preaching continued to be conducted in the town-owned meeting house (the church in East Andover) but these were supported by various religious societies. Some called themselves free-will Baptists, some “Christians,” and some “United Baptists” (You can read all about it in the writings of Ralph Chafee obtainable at the Andover Historical Society). 

In 1840 the Town of Andover finally divested itself of ownership of the Church meetinghouse, giving it to members of the Christian denomination.  They proceeded to give the original 1796 building a thorough renovation including the addition of the entryway with belfry and steeple. Essentially the look of the building today is that of the 1840 renovation (with organ, heat, lights, and plumbing added over the years).

In 1865 the “Christian church” congregation could no longer sustain ministry, but a Congregational society was formed.  In 1869 they called their first pastor, the Rev. Howard Moody. Since that time, except for brief lapses between ministers, there have always been services held with preaching by called pastors and there has always been a continuing congregation.


At Andover Community Church we thought we ought to acknowledge the past and the men and women of Christian faith who for the past 150 years have been together here at ACC for Christian ministry and mission in the town of Andover. We’d like to invite anyone of good will and interest to a service of celebration and giving thanks this coming September 22, 2019.  Following the service there’ll be an outdoor picnic, to which we hope many will come. More information and details about this service will be provided next month.

Cordially yours,
Rev. John Wagner
Pastor, Andover Community Church